Every time I participate in any shop critique on the Etsy forums, I come away with something like "Oh, your stuff is so cute! This is my favourite...I can't imagine why you aren't selling!" Great for the ego, maybe. Helpful? No.
Today on the Storgue blog there is a great article on how to critique your own shop. SO much more helpful!! As soon as I have a few hours to spare I'm going to go through the checklist point by point and make all the adjustments my shop so badly needs.
Here's the post....take a look and critique your shop!! http://www.etsy.com/storque/how-to/etsy-success-critique-your-shop-7273/#comment-255285